“Deepfakes of living performers without consent are a violation of publicity rights in at least 24 U.S. states,” says intellectual property lawyer Miriam Hodge. “Fan-Topia advocates will cry ‘fair use’ and ‘transformative work,’ but replacing an entire performance—the literal sweat and motion of one artist with the likeness of another—is not parody. It is digital identity theft.”
But critics note that Mondomonger’s Patreon earns over $4,000 a month. “When money changes hands,” Hodge counters, “the ‘fan tribute’ defense collapses.” What drives the obsession with Gillan specifically? She occupies a unique space in Fan-Topia: tall (5’11”), red-haired, with a career that spans quirky indie ( The Party’s Just Beginning ), physical comedy ( Jumanji ), tragic drama ( Oculus ), and motion-capture heavy sci-fi ( Guardians ). Her face is highly legible to AI algorithms—strong bone structure, consistent lighting in high-resolution films.
Moreover, Gillan represents the almost-cast . Rumor has it she auditioned for Captain Marvel, for Lara Croft, for the new Star Wars lead. Mondomonger’s deepfakes serve as a “visual rebuttal” to casting directors who passed her over. In one video, titled “Karen Gillan as Elizabeth Swan” , the algorithm redubs Keira Knightley’s lines with a Scottish lilt. It is brilliant. It is also unsettling. The timing of Mondomonger’s rise coincides with Hollywood’s most aggressive crackdown on AI. The 2023 SAG-AFTRA strike explicitly won protections against digital replicas without “informed consent and compensation.” Yet those rules govern studios, not individual fans in their basements.
This suggests a specific niche intersection of fandom culture (), a particular content creator or handle ( Mondomonger ), the technology of synthetic media ( Deepfakes ), and the actress ( Karen Gillan , known for Doctor Who , Jumanji , Guardians of the Galaxy ).
If you enjoyed this article, explore our ongoing series: “Mods, Moneyshots, and Morals: The Unregulated World of Celebrity Deepfakes.” Disclaimer: Mondomonger is a pseudonym. No actual Karen Gillan performances were harmed in the making of this article, though her digital likeness remains, for now, unprotected.
Whether that is the future of cinema or its funeral depends on which side of the screen you stand.
At the chaotic, brilliant, and often controversial nexus of this movement stands a digital artist known only by the handle . For the last three years, Mondomonger has been the most whispered-about name in the underground deepfake community, specifically regarding one actress: the flame-haired Scottish powerhouse Karen Gillan .
Mondomonger, reached via encrypted email, disagrees. “I am not stealing,” they wrote. “I am celebrating. Karen Gillan is a chameleon. She has the range to play every role I put her in. The deepfakes aren’t to replace Johansson or Theron. They are visual essays proving Gillan’s versatility. Fan-Topia is about showing what could have been .”
